Welcome to $1.50 Fresh Pizza
-
151 E 43rd St, New York, NY 10017 Hotline: (212) 922-0257
Welcome to the bustling heart of New York City, where culinary delights await at every corner. Amongst the myriad of food options, one establishment has captured the attention of locals and tourists alike: $1.50 Fresh Pizza. Located at 151 E 43rd St, just a stone's throw from Grand Central Station, this hidden gem stands as a beacon of affordability and flavor in a city known for its iconic pizza.
At $1.50 Fresh Pizza, the mantra is simple: great pizza at an unbeatable price. For just $1.50, you can savor a fresh slice of cheese pizza that offers a delightful balance of gooey cheese and zesty tomato sauce. This casual eatery embraces the spirit of New York's pizzerias with its welcoming atmosphere and quick service, making it the perfect spot for a speedy lunch or a late-night snack.
- Special Deals: The menu features a variety of mouth-watering options, including two cheese slices with a refreshing drink for just $4.00, or a hearty 18" Meat Lovers Pie priced at $24.00 – ideal for sharing with friends or family.
- Order by the Slice: Choose from an array of toppings beyond the classic cheese, including pepperoni, jalapeños, and mushrooms, all reasonably priced at $2.25 a slice, ensuring that there's something for every palate.
- Convenience: The eatery operates on a cash-only basis, a throwback to simpler times, but don't let that deter you. The speedy service means you'll be in and out in no time, ready to continue your New York adventure.
Customer reviews echo the sentiment that $1.50 Fresh Pizza isn't just about saving a buck; it's about enjoying a delicious slice that embodies the rich culture of New York pizza. From busy families to individuals seeking a quick bite, this pizzeria has garnered praise for its flavorful offerings and efficiency. For instance, one satisfied customer, Justin J., highlighted how their whole pizza pie and drinks came at a mere $23—an astounding deal considering the NYC dining landscape!
As I stood in line, the mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked pizza enveloped me, teasing my taste buds in anticipation of the deliciousness to come. The cheese slice I devoured was hot, cheesy, and just the right amount of greasy—a quintessential New York experience. And with the added option of various condiments to customize your slice, each visit feels like a personal culinary adventure.
If you find yourself in the city that never sleeps, do not miss the chance to dine at $1.50 Fresh Pizza. Indulge in a delicious slice that combines value and taste—it's a true testament to the art of pizza-making in New York. After all, in a place full of culinary masterpieces, sometimes the best discoveries come from the simplest spots. So grab a slice and enjoy the vibrance of the city, one delicious bite at a time!
Unbeatable Value and Flavor at $1.50 Pizza on 43rd Street! We stumbled upon this gem of a pizza spot on 43rd Street during our family spring break trip to NYC, and it was a total game-changer! Conveniently located less than a block from our hotel, $1.50 Pizza became our go-to for a quick, delicious, and budget-friendly meal. After a long day of adventuring around the city, we grabbed a whole pizza pie with pepperoni and four bottles of pop for only $23--talk about a steal! The pizza was hot, tasty, and made fresh right in front of us, with a perfect balance of gooey cheese, tangy sauce, and spicy pepperoni. The value here simply can't be beat, and the taste was just as impressive as the price. It was the perfect meal to bring back to our hotel room, letting us unwind and refuel after a busy day exploring NYC. If you're looking for a quick, affordable, and satisfying bite in the heart of the city, this spot on 43rd Street is a must-try. We'll definitely be back on our next visit!
Needed a quick bit to hold me over for dinner. Can't beat $1.50 a NY slice, smaller than expected but it was more than enough before dinner. Small place, but packed with big goodness inside. **CASH only Thank goodness I had a $5 in my purse! Had a little line, but went by really fast. Service was great and fast and nothing more I can ask! All the condiments were on the side and I ate my pizza as I walked back to the hotel. I think I'm used to Costco sliced cheese pizza because I think that is better, nonetheless, I had my NY pizza fix.
Grabbed a plain pie for $12 and took it up to the room at Westin grand central. The guy at the counter (who was also the cook, yeah real big place) was friendly enough. The pizza tasted good, I wish it was cooked a bit longer though. I could have asked for well done and didn't so I'll take that on me. They also cooked it on a screen which I don't love. I want that bottom of the pizza right on the stone. Cheese to sauce ratio was solid and the dough had good flavor. All in all, I'd grab another one and ask for it crispy. Not the best you're getting in NYC by a long shot, but it Didn't Suck.
RIP, 99-cent pizza, but $1.50 still ain't bad. We came here for a quick lunch as the wafting pizza smells in the streets of New York beckoned me here. There was a short line but it moved quickly. Cash in hand, I ordered two cheese slices and it was hot and ready. They also have seasonings on the side of the counter to zhuzh it up. The default serving method is on a paper plate, but a small takeout box for your slice(s) is available upon request. They have some meal deals to save some change on a beverage, such as two cheese slices and a can of soda or water for $4. You can also get two slices with one-topping and a can of soda or water for $5.50. There's no extra savings if you choose to get the 18" cheese pie ($12, which still comes out to $1.50/slice). But hey, cheap and delicious New York pizza- it'll do in a pinch.
Feed a crowd for cheap in NYC. They accept Cash only! Pizza was good, cheesy and just the right amount of grease. Cheap napkins.
The year is 2024 and the 99 cent slices are now $1.50 and the 18" pies are now $12. No complaints, as it's still pretty clutch as a spot around grand central station to grab a quick slice while waiting for the train late at night. Folks behind the counter are friendly and service is quick. Three of us devoured the pie in less than ten minutes. Is it really a classic New York cheese slice? Welllll, it's more like a classic value slice... like a cheesy bread w a bit of tomato sauc
Honestly one of the best dollar pizza in NY. I can't see why anyone would be dissatisfied from this dollar pizza. It has a good balance of cheese, sauce, and bread and it's quick! Perfect for a quick bite and the service was fast. Always come here for a quick snack when I have the time and craving pizza
This was our first trip to NYC with our tween daughters who expressed an interest in seeing some Broadway shows. When planning/preparing for this trip, we knew this would not be a cheap vacation. Air fare to NYC from Honolulu = $$$$. Tickets to 4 Broadway shows = $$$$. Hotel in Times Square for a week = $$$$. Given the speed that money was being drained from my wallet, 99 Cent Fresh Pizza was definitely the best find on our trip! 99¢ for a huge slice of cheese pizza!!! $8 for a whole cheese pie!!! Our daughters are 13 years old - they would happily eat cheese pizza every day!!! Win - win!!! Can get busy (of course) so expect a line - especially during lunch time. Slices with other toppings (pepperoni, etc.) cost a bit more.